thumbnail

In a political landscape still reeling from the 2024 election, a new battle is brewing that could reshape American democracy: the 2026 gubernatorial races. With 36 governorships up for grabs, these elections are not just about state-level policies—they are a referendum on the future of election integrity, especially in key battleground states. And early signs suggest a surprising trend: Democrats are gaining ground in places once considered safely Republican, leaving former President Donald Trump and his allies scrambling to respond.

The High-Stakes Battle for State Houses

Governors play a critical role in certifying election results, a fact that has taken on heightened significance in the aftermath of the 2020 election and the January 6 insurrection. In several swing states, Democratic incumbents are fighting to retain their seats against Republican challengers who have questioned or outright denied the legitimacy of past elections. The outcomes could determine whether the 2028 presidential election is certified smoothly or mired in controversy.

Take Pennsylvania, where Democratic Governor Josh Shapiro is seeking a second term. Shapiro, a former attorney general, made national headlines for his staunch defense of the 2020 election results, suing Trump and his allies multiple times over attempts to overturn the vote. In a recent debate, he touted his record: "I was the Attorney General in the 2020 election. When Donald Trump and his enablers, including my opponent, sued us 43 different times to try and throw out the votes of the good people of Pennsylvania... I won, Donald Trump lost again, and your right to vote is protected."

Shapiro's opponent, Republican Stacy Garrity, has aligned herself closely with Trump, raising concerns about whether she would certify a Democratic victory in 2028. Shapiro warned, "I'll certify whoever the people choose. I don't know that we can say the same about my opponent, who takes her direction on these matters seemingly from Donald Trump."

Polling in Pennsylvania shows a tight race, but recent forecasts have shifted in Shapiro's favor, buoyed by his strong approval ratings and a well-funded campaign. The Cook Political Report recently moved the race from "toss-up" to "lean Democrat," a significant development that has national implications.

Arizona: The Frontline of Election Denialism

Perhaps no state is more emblematic of the threat to election integrity than Arizona. Democratic Governor Katie Hobbs, a former secretary of state who stood firm against pressure to overturn the 2020 results, is running for reelection. Her likely opponent is Congressman Andy Biggs, a prominent election denier who has refused to acknowledge President Biden's 2020 victory and was involved in efforts to submit fake electors for Trump.

In an interview, Hobbs did not mince words: "Andy Biggs is not just a run-of-the-mill election denier. He is a very special one. As a member of Congress, he refused to certify Arizona's electors, but he also was part of orchestrating the fake elector scheme... He helped plan January 6th. This is something he sought a presidential pardon for and has never answered for."

Arizona is unique because it is the first swing state in the Electoral College certification order, meaning its governor could play a pivotal role in the 2028 presidential election. If Biggs wins, Arizona would become the first swing state overseen by an election denier, raising fears of a constitutional crisis. Hobbs emphasized, "We have to win this election to protect our democracy."

Current polling shows Hobbs with a narrow lead, but the race is far from decided. National Democrats are pouring resources into Arizona, recognizing its outsized importance. The Democratic Governors Association (DGA) has identified Arizona as a top priority, alongside other battlegrounds like Nevada, Georgia, and Wisconsin.

The Expanding Map: Blue Waves in Unlikely Places

The battle for governorships is not limited to traditional swing states. In a startling development, race forecasters have shifted their ratings in several Republican-leaning states toward Democrats. The Cook Political Report recently moved the Alaska gubernatorial race from "toss-up" to "lean Democrat," and similar shifts have been noted in Oklahoma, Vermont, and Nebraska.

In Alaska, incumbent Republican Governor Mike Dunleavy is facing a tougher-than-expected challenge from Democratic candidate Les Gara, a former state legislator. Gara has focused on kitchen-table issues like the high cost of living, but he also emphasizes the importance of protecting democracy. The DGA's Ofira Yasko explained, "People are understanding more than ever that who your governor is has never mattered more... Democratic governors in particular are really good at responding with plans and policies for how they're going to put money back in your pocket."

Trump himself has taken notice, making a rare trip to Wasilla, Alaska, to rally for Republican candidates. "The golden age of America is upon us, but you must get out and vote Republican," he urged. However, his presence may not be enough to stem the tide. Alaska's ranked-choice voting system and a strong Democratic ground game have put the state in play.

In Oklahoma, Democratic candidate Joy Hofmeister is running a surprisingly competitive race against Republican incumbent Kevin Stitt. Hofmeister, a former Republican turned Democrat, has hammered Stitt on issues of corruption and education funding. Similarly, in Vermont, Democratic candidate Brenda Siegel is gaining traction against Republican Governor Phil Scott, who has faced backlash for his handling of the pandemic and his ties to Trump.

Nebraska, typically a Republican stronghold, has also seen a tightening race. Democratic candidate Carol Blood is challenging Republican incumbent Jim Pillen, focusing on rural healthcare and property taxes. While a Democratic win in Nebraska remains an uphill battle, the fact that these states are even competitive speaks to a broader political shift.

Why the Tide Is Turning

Several factors are driving the Democratic momentum in governors' races. First and foremost is the economy. While inflation remains a concern, Democratic governors have been able to point to concrete achievements: expanded healthcare access, tax cuts for working families, and investments in infrastructure. In contrast, Republicans are tethered to Trump's unpopularity and his ongoing legal battles, which have become a drag on down-ballot candidates.

Second, the issue of democracy itself is resonating with voters. The January 6 hearings and the continued spread of election denialism have made many Americans acutely aware of the importance of having leaders who will uphold the rule of law. As Hobbs put it, "I think people can focus on more than one issue at a time, and while affordability is a top issue, this certainly is something that I hear from folks."

Third, the Democratic Governors Association has invested heavily in grassroots organizing and voter turnout, particularly in early voting states. With voting already underway in several states, the DGA's efforts could pay off. Yasko noted, "We have the opportunity to go on offense and play in states that Trump won in 2024... We think those are really incredible places with incredible candidates."

Finally, the Republican Party is fractured. Trump's hold on the GOP remains strong, but his endorsees have struggled in general elections. In Pennsylvania, Garrity's ties to Trump may be a liability in a state Biden won in 2020. In Arizona, Biggs's extremism may turn off moderate Republicans and independents. The result is a map that is expanding for Democrats, forcing Republicans to play defense in states they once took for granted.

The Stakes for 2028 and Beyond

The 2026 gubernatorial races are not just about the next two years—they are about the future of American democracy. Governors elected in 2026 will be in office during the 2028 presidential election, and they will have the power to certify or reject the results. In states like Arizona, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, the difference between a Democratic and Republican governor could determine whether the will of the people is respected.

Trump and his allies understand this. That's why Trump is personally campaigning in places like Alaska, and why his endorsed candidates are echoing his election lies. But voters appear to be rejecting this approach. The shift in race ratings toward Democrats is a clear signal that the politics of division and denial are losing their appeal.

As the election approaches, Democrats are urging voters not to rely on polls but to show up. "Polls don't vote, so you need to register and show up," wrote one commenter, a sentiment echoed by many. With early voting already begun in several states, the time for action is now.

Conclusion: A Turning Point?

The 2026 gubernatorial elections could mark a turning point in American politics. If Democrats can hold onto key battlegrounds and pick up unexpected wins in red states, it would be a repudiation of Trumpism and a victory for democratic norms. If Republicans prevail, particularly in states like Arizona and Pennsylvania, it could pave the way for further efforts to undermine election integrity.

One thing is clear: the stakes could not be higher. As Governor Shapiro said, "The next governor of this Commonwealth is going to have to decide who to certify in the presidential election of 2028." That decision could determine the future of the republic. Voters have the power to shape that future—if they show up and make their voices heard.